Recently I tried to explain what memes are.
I started into a teacherly explanation about how cultural units behave like genes, getting passed on and, in many cases, mutating into new forms and a hundred visions and revisions. I said, “Think of the peace sign logo, urban myths, advertising jingles, jokes that fly around the internet, or expressions like “meme” where people have to guess at the pronunciation and exact meaning.
Because I couldn’t really remember the name of Richard Dawkins, the guy who originated the term, my lesson wasn’t complete. Later, I realized I called him Richard Dawson, the name of the former host of “Family Feud.”
And I didn’t mention memes people plant, laboratory-created connections passed around deliberately—usually x number things to say about y—appearing with the viral regularity of “Kilroy was here.”
Perhaps my feeling about these planted memes bleeds through my explanation.
Then, in a case of life imitating life, only a day or so after this conversation, I received this meme from one of my favorite bloggers, The Individual Voice:
List your five greatest strengths as a writer
Okay, I’ll comply. I don’t want to be a smartass, but first let me say that catching this meme is, for me, like an actor catching chicken pox. It’s one meme I’d rather not have. My earnestness as a writer is my greatest—and perhaps only real—strength. I try hard. I try hard to find the right word and the right number of words in a good order.
But that leaves me four more, so I’m going to mutate this meme deliberately in two different ways. Here is the first mutation. I’ll list the other four strengths I think writers need, which happen to be ones I hope to have:
2. Love of language: to me, writing requires loving words as little miracles. If at every juncture of choice, a writer settles for what’s good enough, the writing’s spirit will suffer. A little playfulness and desire to surprise goes a long way.
3. Delight in experience, every experience: Some days, I think I belong in the Home For the Easily Amused. I’ve been known to sit in a car outside a movie theatre debating whether to miss the start to listen to an NPR piece on aberrant zip codes. For a writer, everything is fodder for thought.
4. A sense of yourself as yourself and as a human being: Emerson said, “To believe your own thought, to believe that what is true for you in your private heart is true for all men-that is genius.” Well, that’s hooey. We’re different. At the same time, however, writers do need a sense of what lands between familiar and strange. The former without the latter is banal. The latter without the former is synthetic. You aim for what Emily Dickinson called “amazing sense,” the zone between what’s known and unknown that makes writing emotionally as well as intellectually satisfying.
5. Faith in your reader: Readers can smell a writer who doesn’t think enough of them, and every reader-writer relationship is a partnership. I know some writers deliberately confront their readers, and slide them along a sharp edge or hand them stones until they can no longer stand, but even they want readers to stay. Writing is seldom about you in the end. You want to speak, yes, but you also want to be heard. You have to believe you will, that a reader is out there.
Which brings me to the end of my list, and ready to offer my second mutation. Here are five blogs/bloggers I’d love to hear address this question. No obligation—particularly if they don’t visit here to discover this request!
Mariachristina
red Ravine
Loud Solitude
How to Survive a Suburban Life
The Backstage Grumbler
If you feel I’ve eluded this task with my two deliberate mutations, please forgive me. I was only doing with this meme what we all do to real memes, absorbing them as we can, as our own, as something to pass through us before being passed on.
Filed under: Aesthetics, American Life, Art, Blogging, Culture, Dickinson, Emerson, Essays, Forgiveness, Human Nature, Humility, Identity, Life, Memes, Musings, Novelty, Society, Thoughts, Words, Writing

Your meme was actually quite beautiful and I’ve been fascinated and delighted reading different people’s memes. It makes me want to make a list of all the contents of all the lists, but in a way that maintains the individual choices of departure of each lister. Also, I already tagged suburban life, so you will see her list, but I wish you would let the others tagged know only because selfishly I’m very curious about their lists.
Ooh, I’m sorry. I was afraid I might tag an already tagged. I hope that some of those people will write—I’m curious too. I’ll send them notes. —D
Joe: since the individual voice had tagged me also, I had to drop by and see what the others had done. Love the NPR example – sounds like the sort of thing that would keep me enthralled, too!
(note to self – Life is wonderful. Found joefelso’s blog: yet another great excuse for not packing boxes for the upcoming move. )
I’m supposed to be moving too—my office—and writing college recommendation and grading papers and preparing for class. So I’m similarly avoiding it all—your blog is next. —D
I think these are very valid mutations. I especially liked your #2… love of language. You have to want to read words as well as write them all the time… even when creativity is not a requirement. I would rather read a cereal box, than have nothing at all to read.
I’ve read quite a number of cereal boxes too. I don’t have as much time to read as I’d like, but I’m always seeing new words, words in strange contexts, words I’ve never heard used that way, words that sound funny. A few years ago, I kept a little deck of odd and interesting words and pulled two or three to write a daily poem. I threw most of the poems away, and the ones I kept, I usually ended-up removing the word (because “fetlock” is hard to use without attracting attention to it) but the exercise was great. Thank you for validating my mutations—I was afraid I’d cheated. —D
I *love* your explanation of what memes are. I laughed out loud when you mistook Richard Dawkins for Richard Dawson. Gawd, remember how he kissed every woman on his show?! My mom used to say, he’s not going to kiss HER, is he?! Matter of fact, memes are like Richard Dawson, that desire for connection and intimacy.
Your variation on the meme was great. I liked all the items, but I am especially fond of the last one. Wow, the reader. Slap in the forehead…is that right-on or what?
Oh, and I got to the end of post and saw red Ravine. Gosh, I’ll have to let QM know if she doesn’t already. Thanks. We’ll have to think about how to make it a two-person kind of thing.
I don’t know whether you followed that link to “The Richard Dawson Experience,” but I couldn’t tell whether it was sincere or entirely tongue-in-cheek. I have to think they were joking though, as I think they called him “the sexiest man alive.” I think that would be Richard Dawkins, right?
Oddly enough, my students hardly ever think of readers. If they do think of a reader, it’s me. If they are going to write to me, they ought to send a letter or e-mail. I’d rather read something written to interact with readerS. I hope you don’t mind being tagged. I never mind, but I hate passing it on. —D
[...] 4th, 2007 by ybonesy D. from “Joe Felso: Ruminations” wrote an entertaining post on the strengths great writers need. (Entertaining because he started the post with some history [...]
I didn’t know you included me on this list until I went back and read to the end! I guess a good writer had better know how to be a good reader too!
Speaking of meme’s, what about Who is John Galt? I loved that book when I was 17.
I’ll think about what you’ve said here, and post a few of my own. For me, you’re a wonderful role model for writing. I’ll just read your posts and figure out exactly why I keep coming back.
[...] you ever want to learn how to write a soulful, meaningful essay, I invite you to visit the pages of Joe Felso, Ruminations. If you prefer spare poetry rich with vivid images, Joe Felso provides. And if that’s not [...]
I have tracked back to your post, but don’t know why it hasn’t appeared yet. It did appear on the post that tagged me!
It seems WordPress is tracking the meme from its origin – so the person who tagged you gets the trackback first, and the earlier contributors to the meme, whom you trackbacked at the same time, receive it later!
I don’t really understand how the linking part of memes work, but I did go back and read your post. I love the mixture of practical and philosophical advice. Like you, I am a fan of Elements of Style, and I love what you say about writing as a reader. I’m so terribly busy (emphasis on the “terribly”) that I haven’t had time to visit as much as I’d like lately, but I will be back. Thanks for visiting here. —D
Let me first gather my marbles, D. They seem to have scattered. LOL. I am honored you added me to your list, though. Thank you!
You’re welcome. No pressure. I just thought it would be great to hear what you had to say, and I look forward to your response when you can get to it. We teachers are busy this time of year!—D
[...] of Joe Felso, in his September 3 entry intitled, “I Me Me Meme“, [...]
[...] December 15, 2007 by Liz This is part II of my response to joefelso’s tag from his post, I Me Me Meme. [...]
[...] writers who’ve contributed to this before, like Suburban Life, The Individual Voice, Joe Felso, MariaCristina, and of course, Rambodoc. I liked MariaCristina’s way of listing each strength [...]